September 3, 2012

"Transfer" the Palestinians? Reasons Against REBUTTAL

Submitted by SamsonBlinded (Ukraine), Mar 14, 2009 at 11:53
1. Transfer of foreigners cannot be morally wrong by definition because morality is an intra-group phenomenon. Our morality needs conflict with those of Palestinians. Also, something which is standard cannot be immoral, and population transfer took place many times in 20th century.

2. A lot of Israelis are against their state, anyway. Haredim despise Zionist state. Ultra-leftists despise Jewish state. Almost everyone down to hardcore leftists despises Arabs, so the transfer is unlikely to exacerbate tensions. On the contrary, on long-term perspective, the transfer would remove a major reason for Jewish-Arab and right-left divisiveness. Also, why did not the government worry about division when evicting Gush Katif?


Read More:

http://www.danielpipes.org/comments/152270

No comments:

Post a Comment